Justia Badge
Thumbtack Top Pro - 2016
Best of 2016 Thumbtack
The National Trial Lawyers - Top 40 under 40
The National Trial Lawyers - Top 100 Trial Lawyers
Expertise - Best DUI Lawyers in Tampa 2020
Expertise - Best Criminal Defense Lawyers in Tampa 2020
Expertise - Best DUI Lawyers in Tampa 2021

Substantive Motions

Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Substantive Motions

As a Tampa Criminal Defense Lawyer I am asked to explain the types of citizen encounters law enforcement quite frequently make.

What is a Consensual Encounter?

It is obvious that a police officer does not need a well-founded suspicion of criminal activity to simply approach someone and start talking to them. It also makes sense that during this encounter that person is free to leave at anytime. That individual can either choose to voluntarily comply with the officer’s request or chose to ignore them. As a Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney, my advice is if you are approached by law enforcement and are questioned politely ask that officer directly if he has probable cause to make an arrest. If he says no, I would stop talking, wish the officer well, and leave immediately.

What is an Investigatory Stop or a Terry Stop?

Florida has adopted the Stop and Frisk Law which says that in part that, whenever a law enforcement officer encounters any person under circumstances which reasonably indicate that that individual has committed, is committing, or is about to commit a crime the police officer may detain that person on a temporary basis to question that person on his or her involvement with the crime. However, that individual may not be detaining for longer than is reasonably necessary to determine that involvement. Also, the person may not be relocated and the questioning must take place in vicinity where the individual is detained.

To bring a motion on these grounds, the burden lies with your Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney to show that there was no warrant issued for the defendant’s seizure. Once established, the burden shifts to the prosecution to produce clear and convincing evidence that the warrantless search was legal.

What is a Probable Cause Arrest?

If at any time after the person was detained for questioning via the Terry Stop method enough evidence is obtained that rises to the level of probable cause that person can be legally arrested and held on those charges. If a judge at first appearance determines that probable cause did not exist at the time of the arrest, that judge can order the release the individual. However, the release of the individual does not prevent the prosecution from the filing of formal charges in the future.

Probable cause exists when the police have, at the time of the arrest, knowledge of the facts and circumstances grounded in reasonably trustworthy information that is sufficient in and of itself to warrant a belief by a prudent person that an offense has been or is being committed by the person arrested. Beck v. Ohio, 379 U.S. 89, 91 (1964).

In making an arrest, law enforcement officers typically complete a Criminal Report Affidavit (CRA) or Notice to Appear (NTA) in non-arrest cases. The CRA details the name of the person being arrested, the charge, and the probable cause that existed to make the arrest. The NTA contains the same information, but rather than getting arrested, that individual is ordered to appear in court at a later date.

Some examples of other substantive motions that our Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney routinely file include: Motion to suppress statements taken in violation of Miranda Rights, Motion to suppress traffic stop for lack of probable cause, motion to suppress statements based upon an invalid waiver of rights, and motion to suppress statements based upon the accident report privilege.

Client Reviews
Pallegar Law, always put my family first, their team always explained things in full detail, and got the very best results possible. They genuinely care. Our family will forever be grateful. Thank you. Dennis
He took me on and from the word go communicated everything in a timely and professional fashion about how everything is going to be played it; and then delivered word for word. The best part about them apart from their professionalism and efficiency would have to be their honesty which lets you entrust them, which in today's day and age is a rare virtue. Hemant
Excellent communication skills between the staff and client. I always felt I was in the know as to what to expect next. Ajay was up front on possible outcomes of the case and did not promise unrealistic results. Hope to not need them again, but definitely would recommend them. Steve
Ajay made me feel like I was the only case he had, and that he put all of his time making sure I was properly defended. Thanks to Ajay professionalism and attention to detail all my charges were dropped. I one hundred percent recommend Ajay Pallegar as your next defense lawyer. Eric