Justia Badge
Thumbtack Top Pro - 2016
Best of 2016 Thumbtack
The National Trial Lawyers - Top 40 under 40
The National Trial Lawyers - Top 100 Trial Lawyers
Expertise - Best DUI Lawyers in Tampa 2020
Expertise - Best Criminal Defense Lawyers in Tampa 2020
Expertise - Best DUI Lawyers in Tampa 2021

Casey Anthony Killed her Daughter by Accident?

In 2011, Casey Anthony was found not guilty of the murder of her two-year old child, Caylee. The verdict was met with public backlash with many people believing her to have killed the child with chloroform.

The child was reported missing by Casey’s mother, Cindy Anthony, in a 911 call where she said that she had not seen the child for more than 30 days. Casey gave a number of different statements to detectives regarding the whereabouts of her child-- at one point she claimed Caylee was with a nanny, then she claimed the same nanny had kidnapped the child. The name that she gave, Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez, was found to have no connection with the Anthony family.

Casey was arrested for the first time in July 2008, later being charged with child neglect, obstruction of a criminal investigation, and giving false statements to law enforcement. On December 11, 2008, a trash bag with the remains of the child was found in the woods near the Anthony residence. Caylee’s death was then ruled a homicide.

In July 2011, Casey was found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter, and child abuse. However, she was found guilty of four counts of providing false information to law enforcement. She was sentenced to one year in jail, but was released after less than two weeks for time served. In January 2013, an appeals court reduced her convictions from four down to two.

Six years later the judge who presided over the case gave an interview to HLN. Belvin Perry, a former judge and now attorney, stated that he thinks the death of Casey’s child was an accidental chloroform overdose. Because there was no evidence of prior child abuse he thinks the death was genuinely accidental.

During the trial, two different explanations for the death were offered. The prosecution alleged that the child was killed with chloroform with her nose and mouth covered with duct tape and later dumped in the woods. The defense, on the other hand, alleged that the child drowned in the family’s pool and that Casey’s father helped her cover it up.

Perry stated that Casey had two distinct personas in court. One was specifically for the jury-- “Casey in the presence of the jury was very calm, very easygoing, mild-mannered, in a very sympathetic-appearing person.” However, he stated that when the jury wasn’t in the room, Casey’s attitude quickly changed. “She was quite in charge, quite demanding, and quite manipulative.”

Ultimately, Perry does not blame the jury. He understands that there are many different ways to view the case all-depending on perspective. Despite this he feels that there was enough evidence for a first or second-degree murder conviction. In the end, it is quite possible that the jurors simply didn’t know what happened. If there is that element of uncertainty then that constitutes reasonable doubt. In 2012, Casey made a statement to CNN that her daughter was her “greatest accomplishment.”

In early 2017, Casey was spotted at an anti-Trump political protest outside his estate in Palm Beach, Florida. She declined to speak on camera, but stated she was against Trump’s policies and agenda.

Client Reviews
Pallegar Law, always put my family first, their team always explained things in full detail, and got the very best results possible. They genuinely care. Our family will forever be grateful. Thank you. Dennis
He took me on and from the word go communicated everything in a timely and professional fashion about how everything is going to be played it; and then delivered word for word. The best part about them apart from their professionalism and efficiency would have to be their honesty which lets you entrust them, which in today's day and age is a rare virtue. Hemant
Excellent communication skills between the staff and client. I always felt I was in the know as to what to expect next. Ajay was up front on possible outcomes of the case and did not promise unrealistic results. Hope to not need them again, but definitely would recommend them. Steve
Ajay made me feel like I was the only case he had, and that he put all of his time making sure I was properly defended. Thanks to Ajay professionalism and attention to detail all my charges were dropped. I one hundred percent recommend Ajay Pallegar as your next defense lawyer. Eric